melkmatic's movie Reviews on Newgrounds

[TEH_FISH]

One line summary

That had a really smooth feel to it, the graphics were very slick. As an animation it wasn't anything great, but I did quite like it. The ending was kind of unexpected.

ChrisF responds:

Glad you liked it!

[this has been moved]

One line summary

The sound gets a zero, because I couldn't really hear what that bloke was saying. The graphics are pretty low too, I HATE GRADIENTS, they look shit, and they are used a lot in this. Oh, and when he's a 'god's provider' or whatever, the text on his sash is reversed when he's walking to the left, and that looks shit too. But it made me laugh, so you get 5 humour points for that. Apart from all that, it was a good effort, I can tell you spent a long time on this, and it was well drawn.

[Mr. Grimm - Love]

One line summary

I can tell you've spent a lot of time on this, but you need to spend more time drawing it and animating it. The drawing was very poor.

[Lemonade Stand]

One line summary

What? I thought that was pretty good. The retard was funny and I really wasn't expecting him to shoot himself. Looks like he had a bit of difficulty getting the gun out. Really well done, must have taken ages to do.

[Pablo Nieto]

One line summary

The drawing in that was really good, I think you've got a very unique style. The animation was very good as well, but could probably do with a little touching up here and there. The sound effects kinda let it down I think, good effort for putting some in, but Im not sure they fitted in some places. It could have done with an option for English subtitles, as I think most of your audience on here will be English, and like me, won't have a clue what's going on...

[Carlos Man of Love]

One line summary

It was quite well animated, and it was drawn quite well, even though it uses that hideous gradient tool it looked good. The song was ok, not really my sort of music. I think it was meant to be a humourous piece? But I didnt really laught, except when he revealed the rose... A good effort though.

[Dad's Home]

One line summary

That was good. It was drawn and animated really well, I loved the way the fuzz danced. I could predict a couple of things but on the whole you kept me guessing so I suppose you kind of succeeded. I liked the randomness of it very much. Especially the burning head thing. And the cat.

[Little Fishy's Life]

One line summary

Okay, I didnt have a clue what was going on, but not in a good way. It just looked like a fish swimming around a rock pulling silly faces, but it also seemed like there was some sort of plot hidden there somewhere. It desperately needs a preloader, a replay button, and sound, even if its just an underwater loop from flashkit or something. A good effort though.

[Penguin Jam 2]

One line summary

That was a really good idea, but the animation really let it down. Some of the drawing was quite nice, I like the style of the penguins on the main menu. There was no plot in any of the animations, and it was quite boring the whole way through. Dont give up, you have some good ideas, just spend more time drawing and animating.

[Papertricks 1-6]

One line summary

Thats amazing! Its just like that Peter Gabriel video for Sledgehammer.