melkmatic's movie Reviews on Newgrounds

[Agnès]

Good Drawings...

SOME of the drawings were good, but other than that it sucked. The animation was really bad, the music was depressing, there was a complete lack of plot etc. Good effort though.

Walter-7mm responds:

complete lack of plot?! what are you talking about? this is about my relationship... oh well, the plot must be more vivid to me.

[Xeon's Revenge Part: 1]

One line summary

The blokes all look like they have tits.

Majin-Ryan responds:

errrrm o.....k

[Invisiblity... Rejects]

One line summary

'For whatever reason we were not chosen for the final cut' Maybe because they are poorly drawn and animated and don't follow the theme?

BlackSwordDragon responds:

If you knew the theme maybe you would have thought twice before reviewing... or maybe not might be too hard for you. There was supposed to be a white back ground and someting florishing. We did that.

[Cat's Core]

One line summary

Very nice sketches man, but a little colour and maybe a little more animation would go down a treat. And I'm sure everyone is saying this, but it's a little short...

DoomGirlMeg responds:

Yeah, the next one will be longer. We finished this in one night. The B&W is a stylistic choice, make the blood stand out more, but certain things will be in color, and we've decided to do the final episode completely in color.

[Blob Wars pt. II of ep. 1]

One line summary

Well, I was pretty impressed at that. At first I was thinking, fuck that, those blobs are basically one step up from stickmen. Then I realised it was actually very well drawn and animated. The only things I didn't like were the plotline, because I couldn't follow it, and the soundtrack, but then thats more of an opinion. I think with your drawing skills, you should more effort into drawing proper characters though. Good effort...

3/5

Wattr responds:

Thanks for the advice. Ill keep that in mind with this other cartoon i am working on. the characters look ok.

[Old Zackus Tale: Chapter1]

One line summary

That's was really nice, those graphics are very good. It desperately needs sound though. Hope you don't get bored making this, keep up the good work.

4/5

mazzy responds:

thanks