melkmatic's movie Reviews on Newgrounds

[Agnès]

Good Drawings...

SOME of the drawings were good, but other than that it sucked. The animation was really bad, the music was depressing, there was a complete lack of plot etc. Good effort though.

Walter-7mm responds:

complete lack of plot?! what are you talking about? this is about my relationship... oh well, the plot must be more vivid to me.

[Cartoon Sponsor Me Video]

One line summary

Pretty cool, good to see some other people doing frame by frame non stick skate flash. I know how much fucking effort went into this, so good job. Of course I'm gonna say it's too short, I'm sure loadsa people would have said this. That's the problem with fbf though. Also, the music could have been a bit more original that green day. Just cos it's skating doesn't mean it has to have a punk/grunge soundtrack. Good effort though.

By the way, when punkisdead said:

"style: street. cause no one cares about vert. we're all into street skating aint we. ughhhhhhhhh."

he was quoting Jonny Rotten on the Flip Sorry skate vid where he introduces Rune Glifberg's section. I'm surprised as a skater you didn't know that. Flip Sorry is probably one of the best skate vids ever.

Sibuxiang responds:

Again i'm sorry about the music but i can't please everyone!

It's true it's short. But it's my first!
For the Jonny Rotten quote, i'm sorry but i don't remember every single line in a frickin' skate video! And it doesn't change that i don't agree with that! Besides, why the hell did he quote
someone without even saying who he quoted and that was NOT a constructive review.

Thanks for the nice review tough.

[Xeon's Revenge Part: 1]

One line summary

The blokes all look like they have tits.

Majin-Ryan responds:

errrrm o.....k

[Invisiblity... Rejects]

One line summary

'For whatever reason we were not chosen for the final cut' Maybe because they are poorly drawn and animated and don't follow the theme?

BlackSwordDragon responds:

If you knew the theme maybe you would have thought twice before reviewing... or maybe not might be too hard for you. There was supposed to be a white back ground and someting florishing. We did that.

[Cat's Core]

One line summary

Very nice sketches man, but a little colour and maybe a little more animation would go down a treat. And I'm sure everyone is saying this, but it's a little short...

DoomGirlMeg responds:

Yeah, the next one will be longer. We finished this in one night. The B&W is a stylistic choice, make the blood stand out more, but certain things will be in color, and we've decided to do the final episode completely in color.

[Blob Wars pt. II of ep. 1]

One line summary

Well, I was pretty impressed at that. At first I was thinking, fuck that, those blobs are basically one step up from stickmen. Then I realised it was actually very well drawn and animated. The only things I didn't like were the plotline, because I couldn't follow it, and the soundtrack, but then thats more of an opinion. I think with your drawing skills, you should more effort into drawing proper characters though. Good effort...

3/5

Wattr responds:

Thanks for the advice. Ill keep that in mind with this other cartoon i am working on. the characters look ok.

[Corps Corpse]

One line summary

The animation is pretty smooth,a dn the real fake real fake blood thats really fake but real, looks good, I'm surprised you could use it in stop-motion, I would have thought it would run everywhere. Why did you bother submitting a test though?

ColinMatthews responds:

because i made it, to see how it would look. and i thought it was funny...so...

[Old Zackus Tale: Chapter1]

One line summary

That's was really nice, those graphics are very good. It desperately needs sound though. Hope you don't get bored making this, keep up the good work.

4/5

mazzy responds:

thanks

[ICHHLT-The matrix II]

One line summary

A pretty pointless parody. The graphics were quite well drawn, but there wasn't a lot of animation. It was too short and there wasn't a lot of plot. Good effort though, it's better than my first flashes.

1/5

MarkArandjus responds:

Better than your first flashes?!
That's impossible!
Nothing can suck that bad!

[Maxwell Murders]

One line summary

Pretty average. The graphics and animation weren't crap, but they could have been better.

3/5

LocalNeroflash responds:

pretty average.the overall rating weren't crap.but the review could been bether.

3/5